Techniques
The uncoil coil for varicocele embolization: results in 22 consecutive men
We evaluated the safety and efficacy of a novel varicocele embolization technique, the "uncoil coil" technique, which uses oversized coils deployed by uncovering the coil, rather than traditional coil packing.
Twenty-two consecutive men underwent embolization of the testicular vein with the uncoil coil technique: sodium tetradecyl sulfate foam 3% distally, followed by coil embolization of the remainder of the testicular vein with large-diameter coils deployed without packing. Each coil was advanced through a catheter to the desired location and deployed by withdrawing the delivery catheter over the pusher wire, simply uncovering the coil without packing it in place. All procedures were performed by a single experienced interventionalist. Twenty-five traditional coil packing procedures by the same operator were evaluated retrospectively for comparison.
These results were reported at the 2018 Global Embolization Symposium and Technologies (GEST) meeting.1,2
Purpose
- Determine the efficacy of varicocele elimination utilizing the uncoil coil technique
- Compare outcomes with this single operator's prior experience
Patient details
- 22 consecutive male patients
- Average age 35 (range 20 to 58)
- 12 patients with pain
- 7 patients with infertility
- 3 patients with both
- 50% had a prior varicocelectomy
Pre-procedure evaluation
- Presence of pain, but no scoring
- No evaluation of semen or fertility outcomes
- No clinical varicocele grading
- Testicular ultrasound with grading
Testicular ultrasound (our own internal protocol)
- Grade 0: No reflux or varicosities
- Grade 1: Reflux greater than 1.0 second at the inguinal canal only during the Valsalva maneuver, without a varicocele (no vein larger than 1 mm)
- Grade 2: Varicosities less than 3 mm with reflux greater than 1 second during the Valsalva maneuver
- Grade 3: Varicosities 3 mm or greater with reflux greater than 1 second during the Valsalva maneuver
- Grade 4: Varicosities with nearly continuous or continuous reflux
Grade 3 varicocele
Color Doppler of the left testicular veins at rest and with the Valsalva maneuver, and the spectral Doppler tracing of the reflux.
Uncoil coil technique
- STS 3% foam embolization of the distal testicular vein and pampiniform plexus
- Coil embolization using 15 cm long, 15 to 20 mm Cook MReye coils
- Additional STS 3% foam during the embolization for collaterals and tributaries
How each step is done, with the clips from these procedures: the varicocele embolization technique (venography, groin compression and foam) and the uncoil coil (the coils).
Post-procedure evaluation
- Clinical and ultrasound follow-up in 21 of 22 patients. One patient was lost to follow-up.
- Follow-up testicular ultrasound was performed an average of 45 days after embolization (range 14 to 145 days).1
Embolization procedures
- 24 procedures performed on 22 patients
- 34 testicular veins embolized
- 23 performed from a right internal jugular vein
- 1 performed from a right great saphenous vein (a second attempt, after CT venography suggested a groin approach would facilitate testicular vein catheterization)
Technical success
- Technical success was 94% on the first attempt.1
- 2 patients had a second procedure: 1 right failure and 1 left failure. CT venography was used to identify the testicular vein.
- Technical success reached 100% after the two repeat procedures.1,2
Embolization details
No immediate complications.
- Average coils per treated vein
- 2.5
- Average volume of 3% STS foam per treated vein
- 7 ml
- Average fluoroscopy time
- 351 seconds
Follow-up
- 21 of 22 patients: 1 left-sided embolization lost to follow-up
- 33 of 34 veins embolized: 12 right embolizations and 21 left embolizations
Clinical follow-up
- One episode of varicocele thrombosis with pain, resolved over 2 months
- No new inguinal pain or pain felt to be related to coil placement
- No symptoms suggested coil migration. Imaging to assess migration was not performed.
Pain improvement
15 patients with pain
- 8 bilateral
- 7 left
- 0 right
Complete resolution of pain
- 12 of 15 patients (80%) reported complete pain relief.2
Partial improvement
- 3 patients
- Left varicoceles
- 1 residual reflux
Ultrasound success (grade = 0)
- 21 of 22 patients, 33 of 34 sides
- Reflux was eliminated in 29 of 33 treated veins with follow-up (88%).1
- Right side: 12 of 12 (100%).1
- Left side: 17 of 21 (81%).1
Ultrasound grade reduction
Average ultrasound grade before and after embolization.
- Right
- 2.4 to 0
- Left
- 3.3 to 0.3
Ultrasound failures (grade > 0)
- 4 patients with grade 1 or greater
- All left varicoceles
- 3 of the 4 ultrasound failures were treated for pain: 2 had complete pain relief, and 1 had residual pain with exercise
Ultrasound grade before and after in the four: 4 to 1, 4 to 1, 3 to 3 and 2 to 2.
Ultrasound failure
Varicocele smaller, but persistent reflux with Valsalva.
Potential mechanism for failures
Connection to external drainage, i.e. the great saphenous vein.
Comparison group
- 25 consecutive prior patients treated with a traditional coil packing technique
Reduction in coil usage
- Mean coil use fell from 4.7 to 2.5 coils per treated vein, a significant difference (independent t-test, t(45) = 6.96, p < 0.05).2
Fluoroscopy time
- Mean fluoroscopy time was 450 seconds with coil packing and 351 seconds with the uncoil coil technique. The difference did not reach statistical significance.2
- The prior technique already used relatively few coils. Finding and catheterizing the vein also takes up part of the fluoroscopy time.1
Comparison with a recent series
At the 2018 Society of Interventional Radiology (SIR) meeting, Tarulli and colleagues reported a separate retrospective series of 1,050 patients who underwent varicocele embolization with coils alone or coils plus sodium tetradecyl sulfate (STS).3
The SIR 2018 series
- Fluoroscopy time averaged 20 ± 10 minutes.
- Coil use averaged 7 ± 3 coils.
- Complete technical success was 93.1%.
- The abstract did not report ultrasound outcomes.
The uncoil coil series beside it
- Fluoroscopy time averaged 351 seconds, about 6 minutes, against 20 ± 10 minutes.2,3
- Coil use averaged 2.5 coils per treated vein, against 7 ± 3 coils.2,3
- Technical success was 100% (94% at the first attempt), against 93.1%.1–3
- Follow-up ultrasound showed reflux eliminated in 29 of 33 treated veins (88%). The SIR series reported no ultrasound data.1,3
Conclusions
- The uncoil coil technique is very effective for varicocele elimination. In this series it eliminated reflux in 29 of 33 treated veins at follow-up (88%) and relieved pain completely in 12 of 15 patients treated for it (80%), and partially in the other 3.1,2
- It is an efficacious and safe technique, resulting in varicocele elimination, symptom improvement and reduction in coil use.2 There were no immediate complications. One episode of painful varicocele thrombosis resolved over 2 months, no pain was felt to be related to the coils, and no symptoms suggested coil migration, though migration was not imaged.
- Coil use fell compared with our prior coil packing technique, from 4.7 to 2.5 coils per treated vein.
- Cost reduction, for two reasons: fewer coils, and basic pushable coils.
- Theoretical reduction in fluoroscopy time. In this series it fell from 450 to 351 seconds, a difference that did not reach statistical significance: the prior technique already used relatively few coils, and finding and catheterizing the vein takes up part of the time.
- Reflux can persist after technically successful embolization. External drainage of the testicle may play a role.
References
- Cumming M. The uncoil coil for varicocele embolization. Presented at: Global Embolization Symposium and Technologies (GEST); 2018.
- Rostambeigi N, Allen G, Braun N, Golzarian J, Cumming M. Novel “uncoil coil” technique for varicocele embolization. Abstract presented at: Global Embolization Symposium and Technologies (GEST); 2018.
- Tarulli E, Jaberi A, Jaffer H, et al. Varicocele embolization with endovascular coils versus coils and sclerotherapy: an analysis of technical and clinical outcomes from a large retrospective series of over 1000 patients. J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2018;29(4 suppl):S157-S158. Abstract 367. doi:10.1016/j.jvir.2018.01.407