Techniques

Varicocele embolization: venography, compression and STS foam

Varicocele embolization has two related tasks: close the refluxing testicular vein and treat the communicating veins that can leave reflux behind. In this technique, sodium tetradecyl sulfate (STS) 3% foam treats the distal testicular vein and proximal pampiniform plexus, with additional foam for smaller collaterals and tributaries. Long coils treat the main vein and larger parallel veins.1

Groin compression controls the distal passage of foam. Venography first shows the vein and confirms that external pressure at the inguinal ligament controls flow into the varicocele. The pressure is then adjusted under fluoroscopy as the foam is delivered. The distinction matters: the technique fills the proximal pampiniform plexus while keeping foam out of the varicocele itself.1

This page follows that complete treatment sequence. The coil deployment and its rationale are illustrated further in the uncoil coil technique for gonadal vein embolization. The clinical and ultrasound findings are reported separately in the results in 22 consecutive men.

Who the technique was used for

In the GEST series, the technique was used in 22 consecutive men, average age 35 (range 20 to 58). Twelve were treated for pain, 7 for infertility and 3 for both. Half had already had a varicocelectomy: the same situation as the two venographic studies in the next section, which looked for the anatomic reasons surgery had failed.1

Before treatment, the presence of pain was recorded but not scored, the varicocele was not graded clinically, and semen and fertility outcomes were not evaluated. Every man had testicular ultrasound, graded on the series' own internal protocol. The same grading measured the result after embolization.1

Testicular ultrasound grading (internal protocol)

  • Grade 0: No reflux or varicosities
  • Grade 1: Reflux greater than 1.0 second at the inguinal canal only during the Valsalva maneuver, and absence of varicocele (vein > 1 mm)
  • Grade 2: Varicosities less than 3 mm with reflux greater than 1 second during the Valsalva maneuver
  • Grade 3: Varicosities 3 mm or greater with reflux greater than 1 second during the Valsalva maneuver
  • Grade 4: Varicosities with nearly continuous or continuous reflux

The men and the grading are set out with the results: patient details, and the testicular ultrasound grading with a grade 3 example.1

Map the venous pathways

A refluxing gonadal vein may have a parallel channel or communicate with other veins. The treatment plan therefore depends on the venous map, including what remains open after an initial segment has been treated.

In a study of 33 men referred after failed surgery for a left varicocele, venography found incompetent gonadal drainage in 31. Duplication of the gonadal vein was the most common finding, reported in 66% of cases. This was a selected group with recurrent disease, not a prevalence estimate for all men with a varicocele.2

A separate review of 106 primary and salvage embolization patients found inguinal collaterals more often after failed surgical treatment: 27.8% in the salvage group versus 6.7% in the primary group. These findings support the attention paid to parallel veins and tributaries during venography; they do not establish that one embolization method is superior.3

Uncoil coil technique

  • STS 3% foam embolization of the distal testicular vein and pampiniform plexus
  • Coil embolization using 15 cm long, 15 to 20 mm Cook MReye coils
  • Additional STS 3% foam during the embolization for collaterals and tributaries

The sequence uses foam first in the distal vein, followed by coil embolization and further foam where smaller communicating vessels are identified. The 3% concentration and coil dimensions above describe the GEST technique.1

In the GEST series, an average of 7 ml of 3% STS foam was used per testicular vein treated. The series reported that one total for each vein, not separate volumes for the distal injection and the later foam for collaterals and tributaries.1 The other figures for each vein are in the embolization details with the results.

Access to the testicular vein

In the GEST series, 23 of the 24 procedures were performed from the right internal jugular vein, in the neck. The other was a second attempt, performed from the right great saphenous vein, because CT venography had suggested that a groin approach would make it easier to catheterize the testicular vein.1

When the testicular vein cannot be catheterized

Technical success on the first attempt was 94%. The two failures, one on the right and one on the left, were testicular veins that were not catheterized at the first procedure. CT venography was then used to identify the testicular vein, both men had a second procedure, and with those two procedures technical success was 100%.1

The embolization procedures and technical success are set out with the results.

Venography and compression

  • Fill the distal testicular vein and proximal pampiniform plexus with contrast
  • External compression at the inguinal ligament under fluoroscopic guidance, to confirm control of flow into the varicocele

The contrast injection provides a visible test of the compression before foam is injected. Positioning pressure over the groin is only part of the maneuver: the venogram must show that the intended flow is controlled. In the clip, the distal vein and upper plexus fill while the compression instrument lies across the inguinal region.1

Contrast fills the lower testicular vein and the upper plexus while the instrument compresses the groin at the inguinal ligament.

STS 3% foam embolization

  • Initial foam injection with compression
  • Slowly release the pressure and allow foam to fill the proximal pampiniform plexus
  • Do not allow foam into the varicocele

The foam is introduced while compression is maintained. Pressure is released gradually, allowing controlled filling of the proximal plexus. The instruction to keep foam out of the varicocele remains central throughout the injection; filling the entire scrotal varicocele is not the intended endpoint of this sequence.1

Foam displaces the contrast above the groin compression, then passes into the upper plexus below it.

Initial coil

  • Maintain external groin compression to prevent foam entering the varicocele
  • Advance the coil, typically 15 to 20 mm and 15 cm long, to the distal testicular vein
  • Pull back to the pusher wire to determine the proximal landing zone

Compression continues during placement of the first coil so that the change from foam to coil delivery does not release the distal flow control. Pulling back to the pusher wire identifies the proximal landing zone before the coil is uncovered.1

The first coil, still straight inside the delivery catheter, runs down the left testicular vein to the pelvis.

Coil deployment

  • Pin the pusher wire and uncover the coil by withdrawing the delivery catheter over the wire (similar to deploying a self-expanding stent)
  • Occasionally check the proximal landing by pulling the pusher wire back

The coil is uncovered along the vein by withdrawing the catheter over a fixed pusher wire. The coil deployment clip and annotations show this movement in detail.1

Repeat venography

  • Identify parallel veins
  • Coil embolization of larger veins
  • Foam STS for smaller veins, collaterals and tributaries

The next venogram looks for channels that remain open beside the first coil. In this sequence, larger parallel veins receive coils; smaller veins, collaterals and tributaries receive additional STS foam. The clip shows why the treatment continues beyond placement of the initial coil: contrast still fills the testicular vein beside the coil, a second vein running parallel to it, and small side branches.1

After the first coil, contrast fills the vein beside the coil, a second parallel vein and small side branches.

Additional coil embolization

  • Coil larger parallel veins
  • Same deployment technique
  • Monitor the proximal landing by pulling the pusher wire back

The additional-coil clip shows the same uncovering method applied to a parallel vein.1

Final coil

  • Determine the proximal landing
  • Avoid the desire to "nail" the origin of the testicular vein
  • Liberal use of monitoring the proximal end, by pulling the pusher wire back to visualize the end of the coil

Avoid trying to place the final coil exactly at the testicular-vein origin, and repeatedly visualize the proximal coil end. The final-coil clip shows this part of the demonstration.1

Why control the passage of foam?

Reiner and colleagues treated 16 adolescents with 3% STS foam and pushable fibered coils. They used compression during distal injection to limit passage into the pampiniform plexus. Fifteen had documented disappearance of the varicocele. One patient with a bleeding disorder developed 48 hours of scrotal discomfort after deliberate foam entry into the plexus produced phlebitis. This small adolescent series supports the reason for limiting distal foam passage; it did not test the uncoil coil method.4

Venous communications also matter beyond the scrotum. In a later series using a different sclerosant (polidocanol foam), Pitrone and colleagues found that compression or scrotal ligation controlled shunt flow sufficiently for treatment in some patients, but not all. In their series, 22 men had variant venous anatomy. Three had a duplicated vein without a shunt and needed only a more distal injection. The other 19 had shunts to other veins: in 9, sclerotherapy was completed with manual compression, scrotal ligation or both; in 10, those maneuvers did not stop flow through the collaterals. When they could not interrupt flow through the communicating veins, sclerotherapy was stopped and the patients were referred for surgery. That experience supports verifying flow control rather than assuming that the same compression maneuver works for every venous pattern.5

Potential mechanism for failures

Connection to external drainage, i.e. the great saphenous vein.

This pathway could explain persistent reflux despite successful testicular-vein embolization. It remains a proposed mechanism, not proof that every residual varicocele was supplied through the great saphenous vein.1

Four left-sided varicoceles had residual reflux on follow-up ultrasound in the series. On the ultrasound grading above, two fell from grade 4 to grade 1, and two were unchanged, one at grade 3 and one at grade 2. In the example shown with the results, the varicocele was smaller, but reflux persisted with Valsalva (ultrasound failure). Two of the three patients in this group who were treated for pain had complete pain relief; one still had pain with exercise. The anatomic result and the symptom result therefore need to be assessed separately.1

Tortuous veins from the varicocele connect with a large vein that runs down into the thigh.

Assessing the result

The GEST series used clinical review and testicular ultrasound after embolization, with follow-up ultrasound obtained at an average of 45 days, ranging from 14 to 145 days. Follow-up was available for 21 of 22 men. Pain was recorded without a formal pain score, and semen parameters and fertility outcomes were not evaluated.1

There were no immediate complications. One episode of varicocele thrombosis with pain was reported in the GEST series; it resolved over two months. No new inguinal pain or pain felt to be related to coil placement was reported.1 No symptoms suggested coil migration, but no imaging was done to look for it.1

Successful catheter treatment, elimination of reflux on ultrasound and relief of pain are different endpoints. The complete results give the follow-up findings and the limits of the series.

Cases

  • Recurrent varicocele after incomplete embolization: an earlier embolization had closed only the upper part of the left testicular vein. The man had an asymptomatic compression of the left renal vein, and collateral veins from the renal vein carried blood around the old coils into the untreated lower vein, so the varicocele and the pain came back. He was treated again through direct puncture of the distal testicular vein (antegrade access), with coils and then sclerotherapy, and his symptoms resolved. The untreated lower segment is the part of the vein this technique treats first, with foam.
  • Painful bilateral varicoceles in a high school athlete: two years of worsening pain in both testicles that interfered with school sports. Both sides were treated with embolization and foam sclerotherapy.

The technical points

  • Use contrast to map the distal vein and confirm that compression controls flow into the varicocele.
  • Begin foam injection under compression and release pressure slowly to fill the proximal pampiniform plexus.
  • Keep foam out of the varicocele and maintain compression during the initial coil placement.
  • Repeat venography for parallel veins, collaterals and tributaries; use coils for larger veins and foam for smaller channels.
  • Recheck the proximal coil end during deployment.
  • Assess both symptoms and reflux after treatment; a technically successful embolization may leave residual reflux.

References

  1. Cumming M. The uncoil coil for varicocele embolization. Presented at: Global Embolization Symposium and Technologies (GEST); 2018.
  2. Jargiello T, Drelich-Zbroja A, Falkowski A, Sojka M, Pyra K, Szczerbo-Trojanowska M. Endovascular transcatheter embolization of recurrent postsurgical varicocele: anatomic reasons for surgical failure. Acta Radiol. 2015;56(1):63–69. doi:10.1177/0284185113519624.
  3. Rais-Bahrami S, Montag S, George AK, Rastinehad AR, Palmer LS, Siegel DN. Angiographic findings of primary versus salvage varicoceles treated with selective gonadal vein embolization: an explanation for surgical treatment failure. J Endourol. 2012;26(5):556–560. doi:10.1089/end.2011.0387.
  4. Reiner E, Pollak JS, Henderson KJ, Weiss RM, White RI Jr. Initial experience with 3% sodium tetradecyl sulfate foam and fibered coils for management of adolescent varicocele. J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2008;19(2 Pt 1):207–210. doi:10.1016/j.jvir.2007.08.013.
  5. Pitrone P, Silipigni S, Stagno A, Cinquegrani A, Cattafi A, Bottari A. Retrograde sclerotherapy of male varicocele with veno-venous shunts – incidence and management: a single-centre experience. Br J Radiol. 2023;96(1145):20221061. doi:10.1259/bjr.20221061.